Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Activites
Talking to Hamas is a step toward peace
Talking to Hamas is a step toward peace
Barack Obama?s apparent willingness to engage with Hamas is heartening. Peace cannot be achieved without talking to all sides
The first response to word that Barack Obama is prepared to make contact – albeit low-level and clandestine – with Hamas should be caution.
Saturday, March 28,2009 01:43
by Jonathan Freedland Guardian

The first response to word that Barack Obama is prepared to make contact – albeit low-level and clandestine – with Hamas should be caution.

For one thing, the very act of revealing such a move can make it less likely. If the Obama camp comes under heavy criticism from those opposed to engagement with Hamas, it may be forced to deny it countenanced the idea at all. Obama has been super-careful to say next to nothing during the Gaza crisis – and certainly nothing at odds with the Bush administration. He would clearly not have chosen to make this policy shift public. (That said, it"s bound to be welcomed by those in the Muslim world who have been angered by his virtual silence this last fortnight.)

Second, even the limited opening to Hamas apparently under discussion in the Obama circle is pretty conditional. It seems to be premised either on Hamas taking a "decisive drubbing" in Gaza or on a reconciliation with Fatah. Neither of those outcomes is guaranteed.

Nevertheless, those of us who have long believed that peace depends on engaging with all parties to a conflict – and that peace is made with your enemies rather than with your friends – have reason to be cheered by this news, tentative as it is.

It suggests that Obama means to follow through on the principle he articulated repeatedly in the 2008 election campaign: that diplomacy is not some kind of reward for good behaviour, but rather an essential component in any nation"s toolkit. The US would never foreswear the use of force to advance its vital interests, yet the Bush administration did precisely that with diplomacy – denying itself that essential tool when it came to the nations it consigned to outer darkness: the axis of evil trio of Iraq, Iran and North Korea, along with Syria and, of course, Hamas.

Obama promised to do things differently, saying he would even speak to Mahmoud Ahmadinejad if it would help. The one group he seemed least keen to meet was Hamas, placing clear and steep conditions on any dialogue. Indeed in April 2008 he slapped down former president Jimmy Carter for meeting the Islamist movement. "We must not negotiate with a terrorist group intent on Israel"s destruction," Obama said. "We should only sit down with Hamas if they renounce terrorism, recognise Israel"s right to exist and abide by past agreements."

If the latest signals are to be believed, Obama is now ready to soften the edges of those conditions. For those who believe that, whether we like it or not, Hamas is now part of the Palestinian reality and that no peace can ever come unless all the major players on both sides – Israeli and Palestinian – are included, this is a small, unofficial, unconfirmed but welcome move in the right direction.

The Source

Posted in Activites , Human Rights , Palestine  
Related Articles
Muslim Scholar Unwelcome: Obama Lawyer
Can Obama talk to the Brotherhood?
To Engage or Disengage...That is the Question?
Will Obama go beyond the superficial?
Mishaal: Obama using new language towards Middle East
Nunu: Haneyya asked Obama to turn his words into deeds
Obama’s Middle East moment of truth
Hamas deplores Israel’s ban on events marking Jerusalem as Arab cultural capital
British MP Galloway Barred from Canada Over ’Supporting Hamas’
Israel arrests Hamas members
Obama takes a cue from Clinton era
Hamas: Israel will fail to blackmail us through kidnapping our leaders in WB
Greek and Italian MPs meet with Mishaal, call for recognizing Hamas
Hamas: Our people are not children of a lesser God
Scholars Urge Obama to Push for Democracy in Middle East
Anxiety And Engagement
Obama starts well with Muslims but must do more
Obama’s No Socialist. I Should Know.
Habib: London Conference Reveals Double Standards with Hamas
Hamas parliamentary bloc regrets Egyptian access denial for Jordanian MPs
USA: Top officials urge dialogue with Hamas
European MPs call in meeting with Mishaal for opening dialog with Hamas
Mr. Obama: Don’t let Israel destroy America
Obama backs off on Israel, again
Why Hamas is no ‘extremist’
Europe moves towards talking with Hamas
Kouchner: France ready to open talks with PA unity gov’t including Hamas
Open Letter to President Obama about Democracy Promotion in the Middle East and the Muslim World
Memo to Obama: don’t abandon Arab democrats
Hamas’s popularity rises after Israel’s Gaza war
Expert: Obama’s Administration Prioritises settlement of Arab-Israeli Conflict
Dealing with Hamas: Can the U.S. Avoid It?
Bi-Partisan Group of Prominent Scholars and Experts Urge President Obama to Make Democracy
Iraqi MB: Obama’s Decision to Withdraw a Step in the Right Direction
Senior EU delegation to meet with Hamas leadership soon
Take Action on President Obama’s FY2010 Budget Request for Military Aid to Israel
Hamas demands Arab and Islamic stands against Israeli violations
Mashaal: The resistance is a strategic choice of Hamas
Abbas has no right to ask Hamas to recognize Israel
German politician urges Europe to talk to Hamas
Hamdan welcomes European calls for renouncing policy of isolating Hamas
Ex-peace negotiators urge direct talk with Hamas
Peace will be achieved only by talking to Hamas
Televised Turkish opinion poll: 68 percent of the Turkish people support Hamas
Hamas delegation to Cairo to initiate bilateral meetings with Fatah
Obama: faith should unite, not divide
Pointers for the Obama Administration in the Middle East: Avoiding Myths and Vain Hopes
Al Baradie’s Call to the Government to Engage MB
Welcome to Obama’s “New Era of Peace”
Why the Muslim World Can’t Hear Obama ?
Report: Obama will deal with the Palestinian cause in the interest of Israel
Thoughts on Obama’s Outreach to the Arab World
Obama allows CIA kidnappings worldwide as first job
Questions for Barack Obama
Obama moves swiftly on Middle East
Obama’s Middle East challenge
Reactions to Obama’s Al Arabiya Interview
Why Did Obama Choose Al-Arabiya for His First Major Interview?
Haniyyah Calls On Obama to Back Palestinians’ Right to Liberty and Independence
Transcript of Obama’s Interview On Al-Arabiya Television
Obama: Regime Rotation
Resilient Arab regimes deaf to Obama’s words
Question for Barack Obama on Middle East Envoys: How come there ain’t no brothers on the wall?
In Case You Missed It, Obama’s Speech at AIPAC
POMED Asks: “As President, What Should Obama Say to the Middle East?”
Editorial: Not In Defense of Obama
Obama’s Palestine choices
Obama, Middle East and the Freedom Agenda
The Muslim Brotherhood is Pro-Dialogue, Engagement of Women and Copts : Habib
Islamist Pragmatists Ripe for Engagement?
U.S. engages Muslim Brotherhood despite Rice
Engaged to Hamas
To Engage or Not to Engage?
We Must Engage With Moderate Muslims
Political Islam: Ready for Engagement?
Engagement or Quarantine: How to Deal with the Islamist Advance
View from Dubai: Why the West must engage Islamists