Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Archive > MB in International press
Egypt's Opposition Misled by Fixation with Mubarak’s Son
Egypt's Opposition Misled by Fixation with Mubarak’s Son
Political opposition in Egypt has been stirred by a recent campaign against Gamal Mubarak, the son of the president Hosni Mubarak, becoming Egypt’s new president in 2011.
Wednesday, December 16,2009 17:47
by Amr Hamzawy Carnegie Endowment
Political opposition in Egypt has been stirred by a recent campaign against Gamal Mubarak, the son of the president Hosni Mubarak, becoming Egypt’s new president in 2011. In particular, Ayman Nour, a key opposition figure and a presidential candidate in 2005, has mobilised a wide spectrum of political groups to present a united front in upcoming legislative and presidential elections in 2010 and 2011, respectively.
Upon closer look, however, Mr Nour’s rallying cry is troubling. In gearing up for elections, the opposition has demonstrated a near complete inability to prioritise the issues essential to its political future, and has squandered its efforts trying to prevent Gamal Mubarak’s succession.
Egypt’s opposition groups, including both legal parties and the Muslim Brotherhood, have been in disarray since the regime introduced stifling constitutional amendments in 2007. These measures limit the oversight powers of the judiciary in elections, fail to set term limits on the presidential mandate, and ban religiously affiliated political activities.
While opposition forces have been exclusively focused on the one issue – Gamal Mubarak’s possible ascendancy – the Egyptian regime has been carefully creating an environment which will sustain its rule. The ruling elite is no newcomer to this game. They have consistently manipulated the political process by preventing the opposition from registering candidates in elections, obstructing the campaign process, and fomenting violence on election day.
In contrast to the ruling elite’s clear direction, the opposition has no guiding compass and is left wandering through the challenges posed by the political agenda in Egypt. Their failure cannot be solely attributed to the regime’s repressive measures – a great part of the responsibility belongs to the opposition parties themselves. 
Since 2005, parties including the liberal Wafd party, Ayman Nour’s Ghad party and the Democratic Front, as well as the Muslim Brotherhood (which is banned but has de facto representation in parliament) have all failed in two major tasks: formulating an elections platform and clear vision for Egypt’s political development, and applying sufficient pressure on the regime for political and economic reform.
Despite its acquisition of an unprecedented 88 parliamentary seats in the 2005 elections, the Muslim Brotherhood has yet to push for serious reform of the political system. Several concerns also remain unresolved in Egyptian and international public opinion regarding the Brotherhood’s positions on equal citizenship rights for Copts and Muslims, women’s participation in politics and freedom of expression.
The opposition parties urgently need to tackle several issues to position themselves for the 2010 and 2011 elections. First, groups have to clarify their stance on the question of domestic and international monitoring of elections. Especially with regard to the latter, the opposition remains divided. 
Second, they have to prioritise calls for the abolition of the emergency law in effect in Egypt since 1981. Finally, parties should be more attuned to new political opportunities, expanding grassroots activities to capitalise on growing protest sentiment among wide segments of the population who are suffering from deteriorating social and economic conditions.
With Egypt’s declining GDP growth, the unemployment rate reaching 10.3 per cent, a poverty rate of 20 per cent, and an alarming level of debt – 76 per cent of GDP – citizens are in desperate need of competent political parties. 
The implications of the upcoming elections will, of course, extend beyond Egypt’s borders. In light of the regime’s recent political manoeuvring and the opposition’s stagnation, the 2010 and 2011 elections in Egypt will test the Obama administration’s stance on democracy in the Middle East. Its position will either demonstrate a commitment to the incumbent regime of the Mubaraks as a strategic ally in a turbulent region regardless of its domestic behaviour, or signal pressure to create better conditions for democratic reform and political competition in Egypt.
The first signals from the Obama administration are not encouraging; the administration has so far put the promotion of democracy low on its list of priorities. Washington has only raised the issue of reform in the context of concessions that Mr Mubarak has already made. The Obama administration has also cut aid to numerous actors and organisations in civil society. 
The campaign organised by Mr Nour is a step in the right direction for the opposition in Egypt, but he and other activists would be wise to adjust their agenda. Only by letting go of their obsession with Gamal Mubarak’s succession and addressing other issues at the core of the upcoming elections can opposition groups counter the regime’s hegemony.
tags: Mubarak’s Son / Gamal Mubarak / Ayman Nour / Opposition / legislative Elections / Constitutional Amendments
Posted in MB in International press  
Related Articles
Egypt’s opposition misled by fixation with Mubarak’s son
MB and Kifaya denounce Regimes' exploitation of media as propaganda for Gamal Mubarak
Gamal Mubarak: Egypt’s Next Unelected President
Ayman Nour blocked from travel
Muslim Brotherhood MP's to attend conference organized by Ayman Nour
Activists petition against Gamal Mubarak.
Ayman Nour’s speech to US Congress: I reject trial of Khairat Al-Shater’s group before martial court
Egypt’s Gamal Mubarak Aims to Underpin Growth
Interview with Ayman Nour
Habib: Yesterday’s Arrests Linked With Gamal Mubarak’s visit to U.S.
Gamal Mubarak Visits DC
Expert: Hidden Aim behind Gamal Mubarak’s Visit to DC
Expert: MB Detainees’ File Wouldn’t meet Same Flexibility as Ayman Nour’s
Ayman Nour
Interview with Ayman Nour on Egypt’s Elections
MB Parliamentary Bloc: The Release of Ayman Nour is a Step in the Right Path
Ayman Nour released
Gamal Mubarak: "We Need Audacious Leaders"
Brotherhood’s Supreme Guide denies supporting Gamal Mubarak for president
Shares Scheme Is Propaganda for Gamal Mubarak, Says Economic Expert
Gamal Mubarak’s Tours Usher In Succession, Says MP
Gamal Mubarak’s Tours Usher In Succession, Says MP
Court Adjourns Ayman Nour Medical Release Verdict
Amr Hamzawi : Gamal Mubarak lacks legitimacy
After Gaddafi, Egypt Opposition Wants Gamal Mubarak To Follow Suit
Ayman Nour may receive presidential pardon, says El-Ghad
Call for Dr. Ayman Nour’s Freedom
Facebook Activists Call for Releasing Ayman Nour on Revolution Anniversary
Mahdi Akef: Muslim Brotherhood Rejects Gamal Mubarak as President
Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood leader slams President Mubarak’s son
Court Refuses Releasing Ayman Nour on Medical Grounds
Egypt’s Parties Committee Seizes Ayman Nour’s Assets, Gives them to Mousa Mostafa
State Court Dismisses Ayman Nour’s Health Release Appeal
Egyptian Opposition Leader Ayman Nour Starts 3rd year Behind Bars
LCHR Egypt Action Alert, Free Ayman Nour
Reactions to Ayman Nour’s arrest
Mubarak’s Son Denies Succession Move
Supporting Dissidents in Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood, Ayman Nour
Mubarak’s Son to Be NDP Leader
Gamal Mubarak: No Deals between the MB and NDP
Mubarak’s Son Attacks Brotherhood
MB Denies Mediation With Gamal Mubarak & Rejects Power Succession
Gamal Mubarak Denies Egypt Reneging on Reform
Mubarak’s Son Met Secretly With Bush and Cheney
Egypt: The Gamal Mubarak Paradox
Mubarak’s Son Proposes Nuclear Program
Gamal Mubarak Speaks of Egypt’s Right To Nuclear Energy