Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Issues > Human Rights
Egypt's Crackdown: When a U.S. Ally Does the Repressing
Egypt's Crackdown: When a U.S. Ally Does the Repressing
US human rights' scale tilts towards allies revealing a biased not so human right advocating US.
Thursday, February 25,2010 06:57

The U.S. government has never been shy to criticize Iran over its dismal human-rights record, particularly since Tehran launched a crackdown on opposition voices following last summer's election. But the U.S. stance remains considerably more subdued when Egypt, Washington's biggest Arab ally in the region, exercises similar bad behavior. And the months ahead will test just how subdued it intends to be.

 On Feb. 8, for example, Egyptian security forces arrested 16 members of the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt's most popular opposition group. Those arrested included three senior members, including the deputy leader, Mahmoud Ezzat. More than 30 others had been arrested in the two weeks prior to that. "They were arrested having done nothing except calling for reform and freedom and for adopting a moderate approach which Egypt needs the most at this time," read a statement posted on the Muslim Brotherhood website on Feb. 9.


For Egypt, which receives an annual $1.3 billion in U.S. military aid, the equivalent of Iran's election drama hasn't unfolded yet. Parliamentary elections are still several months away, and presidential elections aren't slated until next year. But there are signs of an imminent crackdown on opposition groups. U.S. silence on the issue suggests that Cairo may be able to avoid the international spotlight in a way that Tehran did not.

(See the line of political succession in Egypt.)

On Feb. 8, for example, Egyptian security forces arrested 16 members of the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt's most popular opposition group. Those arrested included three senior members, including the deputy leader, Mahmoud Ezzat. More than 30 others had been arrested in the two weeks prior to that. "They were arrested having done nothing except calling for reform and freedom and for adopting a moderate approach which Egypt needs the most at this time," read a statement posted on the Muslim Brotherhood website on Feb. 9.

(See pictures of the soft revolution of the women of Cairo.)


This isn't anything new for the Brotherhood. The group has been banned since 1954, but its popularity — derived mainly through Islamic charity work, calls for political reform and appeals to Muslim religiosity — makes it especially threatening to the authoritarian regime of President Hosni Mubarak. Even so, the Brotherhood has been tolerated to varying degrees over the years, the state having found a way to keep its members in check through a system of arbitrary arrests and detentions that rights groups say are illegal under international law. "It's a repeated situation," says Taha Ali, a political analyst at the Ibn Khaldun Center for Development Studies, a Cairo NGO. "But this time, we're going to see the parliamentary election in the upcoming period, so it's a historical moment for the regime and the Brotherhood."


Indeed, the state has previously detained hundreds of Brotherhood members in the run-up periods before elections, but the upcoming polls (the upper-house vote is scheduled for May, the more important lower-house vote is in November) — and the arrests, detentions and trials that come with them — could set a new historical precedent for two reasons.

First, the Muslim Brotherhood is unlikely to see anything close to the electoral success it enjoyed during the 2005 parliamentary elections, in which the group, whose members run as independent candidates to get around the ban, swept a stunning 20% of the seats in the lower house of parliament, making it the largest opposition bloc to face off against Mubarak's ruling National Democratic Party. The regime now seems ready to make sure that doesn't happen again. Three senior leaders among the 16 Brotherhood members arrested earlier this month, including the deputy leader of the group, are, according to Reuters, being charged with setting up training camps to plan terror attacks as well as setting up an internal body that heeds militant Islamist ideals preached by a firebrand Brotherhood intellectual who was executed in 1966. The Brotherhood, however, renounced violence in the 1970s and still calls for establishing a state based on Islamic law via peaceful, democratic means.


The government crackdown appears to have been triggered by the Brotherhood's own selection of more conservative leaders who have offered their fellow members a more conciliatory approach toward the regime. Joshua Stacher, a political scientist and Egypt expert at Kent State University, says the move likely served to signal that regardless of who leads the group, the government will continue to beat it down. The government, says Stacher, does "not want them participating in legislative elections or syndicate elections or generally," and it would rather see the Brotherhood "withdraw." "They would ideally like the same thing from the Brotherhood that they've been able to achieve with most other sectors of society and the other remaining opposition: complete acquiescence to their terms."


Analysts say the 2005 electoral reforms that allowed for such a large Brotherhood win were induced, at least in some part, by pressure from the Bush Administration — a policy that many say strained relations between the two countries. The new U.S. Administration is playing its cards differently. "I think it's indisputable that there was significant domestic pressure inside of Egypt [in 2005], and that the United States under the Bush Administration, and Europe, both sort of supported those demands in Egypt for freer and fairer elections — and that had an impact," says Michele Dunne, editor of the Arab Reform Bulletin at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. The first round of the parliamentary elections in 2005 constituted the freest and most transparent election Egypt has ever experienced. But, Dunne adds, "Up till now, I see very little interest on the part of the Obama Administration in raising these issues."


Egypt ranks low on the Obama Administration's list of regional priorities. The war in Iraq, the Arab-Israeli peace process and a growing al-Qaeda threat in Yemen are all outranking concerns. And the Administration has also sought to distance itself from some of the more aggressive policies of its predecessor, which Dunne says damaged bilateral relations with important allies like Egypt. "But I don't think they realize that there is real, observable backward movement when it comes to democratization and human rights in Egypt right now," she says. "And I think that the Obama Administration is going to bear some of the blame for this if they don't get engaged in these issues."


tags: Crackdown / Moderate / Engage / Crackdown On MB / Mubarak / Moderate Muslim Brotherhood / U.S. government / crackdown on opposition / President Hosni Mubarak / Joshua Stacher
Posted in Human Rights , IkhwanWeb in Press , MB Understanding , MB in International press  
Related Articles
Not your average crackdown
LIBYA: Progress reverse with crackdown on media
Iran: Crackdown’s Torrent of Abuses
A New Police Crackdown At Muslim Brothers Leaders And University Professors
Egypt: New government crackdown on MB leadership
Egypt crackdown on Brotherhood leaders.
Pro-Democracy Islamists Suffer in Crackdown
Crackdown against Islamists could backfire
Muslim Brotherhood members Arrested in Fayoum in continuing security crackdowns.
Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood students deepens.
Crackdown on university students continues.
In Egypt, succession worries prompting crackdown?
Egypt’s Airport Crackdown
20 Members of the Muslim Brotherhood in Dakahleya faced raids in a pre-dawn crackdown
Egypt: Brotherhood crackdown sees more leaders arrested
Egypt: Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood not working
Crackdown on Egypt’s Islamist bloggers
NDP Prepares for Presidential Elections Amid Muslim Brotherhood Crackdown
State Security Services launched a wide crackdown against high ranking MB figures
Crackdown on Software companies in Damanhur
Several MBs Arrested Across Egypt As Crackdown Intensifies
Egypt: Eight Missing Amid Rising Crackdown on Gaza Demos
Egypt’s Universities Continue Crackdown on MB Students
Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood Students Continues
Largest crackdown on MB this Ramadan
MP Slams Continuous Crackdown on MB in Al Sharqeyya
MB Deputy Chairman Slams Fierce Crackdown Against Muslim Brotherhood
Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood Bookstores
MB Media Advisor Condemns Crackdown On MB Publishing Houses
Protest Crackdown on Workers’ Movement in Egypt
Muslim Brotherhood to Boycott Local Elections in Egypt After Crackdown
HRW: Egypt’s Crackdown Against MB is Shamless Bid to Fix Vote
Crackdown on Egypt’s Brotherhood personnel
Crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood
MAS Condemns Arrest of Ikhwanweb Editor and Crackdown on Activists
Dozens of MBs Arrested during a Crackdown in 3 governorates
Crackdown Continues in Monoufiya
Rights groups urge press, civil society to speak out against Brotherhood crackdowns
Crackdowns On Bloggers Increasing, Survey Finds
Rice voices concern over crackdown on journalists, dissidents in Egypt
Crackdowns On Bloggers Increasing, Survey Finds
Egypt Arresting Brotherhood Students In Recent Crackdown
Mubarak’s crackdown on labor activists continues…
Jittery Egypt renews government crackdown on dissent
Egypt Renews Crackdown on Islamic Opposition
Police arrest two Muslim Brotherhood lawmakers in latest crackdown
Egyptian police step up Muslim Brotherhood crackdown
Egypt queries new Muslim Brotherhood crackdown
Dismay as Egypt intensifies its crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood
NGO’s Report: Crackdowns and Blockage of Voters are the Titles of 3rd Round
Egypt continues crackdown on reformists as US appears distracted with other issues
Government Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood Continues
Egypt police change tactics in Brotherhood crackdown
Egypt extends emergency law as crackdown on protesters continues
Egypt Crackdown on Opposition is a Mistake: US
Action call: protest crackdown on Egyptian civil rights
The Crackdown in Cairo
Egypt: Police Crackdown On Kifaya Movement
Crackdown on Muslim Brotherhood Deepens
Egypt: MB Candidates Win despite Vote Rigging, Crackdown