Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
Peace might upend wealth of Israelis
Peace might upend wealth of Israelis
With the resumption of settlement construction in the West Bank yesterday, Israel's powerful settler movement hopes that it has scuttled peace talks with the Palestinians, too.
Wednesday, September 29,2010 17:14
by Jonathan Cook intifada-palestine.com

 With the resumption of settlement construction in the West Bank yesterday, Israel's powerful settler movement hopes that it has scuttled peace talks with the Palestinians, too.


It would be misleading, however, to assume that the major obstacle to the success of talks is the right-wing political ideology the settler movement represents. Equally important are deeply entrenched economic interests shared across Israeli society.

These interests took root more than six decades ago with Israel's establishment and have flourished at an ever-accelerating pace since Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza Strip after the Arab-Israeli War in 1967.

Even many Israeli Jews living within the recognised borders of Israel privately acknowledge that they are the beneficiaries of the seizure of another people's lands, homes, businesses and bank accounts.

Most Israelis profit directly from the continuing dispossession of millions of Palestinian refugees.

Israeli officials assume that the international community will bear the burden of restitution for the refugees. The problem for Israel's Jewish population is that the refugees now living in exile were not the only ones dispossessed.

The fifth of Israel's citizens who are Palestinian but survived the upheaval of 1948 found themselves either transformed into internally displaced people or the victims of a land-nationalisation programme that stripped them of their ancestral property.

Even if Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, signed away the rights of the refugees, he would have no power to do the same for Israel's Palestinian citizens, also known as Israeli Arabs. Peace, as many Israelis understand, would open a Pandora's box of historic land claims from Palestinian citizens at the expense of Israel's Jewish citizens.

But the threat to the economic privileges of Israeli Jews would not end with a reckoning over the consequences caused by the state's creation. The occupation of the Palestinian territories after 1967 spawned many other powerful economic interests opposed to peace.

The most visible constituency are the settlers, who have benefited hugely from government subsidies and tax breaks designed to encourage Israelis to relocate to the West Bank. Peace Now estimates that such benefits alone are worth more than US$550 million (Dh2 billion) a year.

Hundreds of businesses serving the settlers are booming in the 60 per cent of the West Bank, the so-called Area C, which falls under Israel's full control. The real estate and construction industries, in particular, benefit from cut-price land – and increased profits – made available by theft from Palestinian owners.

Other businesses, meanwhile, have moved into Israel's West Bank industrial zones, benefiting from cheap Palestinian labour and from discounted land, tax perks and lax enforcement of environmental protections.

Much of the tourism industry also depends on Israel's hold over the holy sites located in East Jerusalem.

This web of interests depends on what Akiva Eldar, of the Haaretz newspaper, terms "land-laundering" overseen by government ministries, state institutions and Zionist organisations. These murky transactions create ample opportunities for corruption that have become a staple for Israel's rich and powerful.

But the benefits of occupation are not restricted to the civilian population. The most potent pressure group in Israel – the military – has much to lose from a peace agreement, too.

The ranks of Israel's career soldiers, and associated security services such as the Shin Bet intelligence service, have ballooned during the occupation.

The demands of controlling another people around the clock justifies huge budgets, the latest weaponry (much of it paid for by the United States) and the creation of a powerful class of military bureaucrat.

While teenage conscripts do the dangerous jobs, the army's senior ranks retire in their early forties on full pensions, with lengthy second careers ahead in business or politics.

Many also go on to profit from the burgeoning "homeland security" industries in which Israel excels. Small specialist companies led by former generals offer a home to retired soldiers drawing on years of experience running the occupation.

Those who spent their service in the West Bank and Gaza Strip quickly learn how to apply and refine new technologies for surveillance, crowd control and urban warfare that find ready markets overseas. In 2006 Israel's defence exports reached $3.4bn, making the country the fourth largest arms dealer in the world.

These groups are concerned that a peace agreement and Palestinian statehood would turn Israel overnight into an insignificant Middle Eastern state, one that would soon be starved of its enormous US subsidies. In addition, Israel would be forced to right a historic wrong and redirect the region's plundered resources, including its land and water, back to Palestinians, depriving Jews of their established entitlements.

A cost-benefit calculus suggests to most Israeli Jews – including the prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu – that a real solution to their conflict with the Palestinians might come at too heavy a price to their own pockets.

* Jonathan Cook is a writer and journalist based in Nazareth, Israel. His latest books are "Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the Middle East" and "Disappearing Palestine: Israel's Experiments in Human Despair".


tags: Peace / Settlement / West Bank / Palestinians / Gaza / Abbas / Jerusalem / Zionist / Netanyahu / Refugees / Gaza Strip / Mahmoud Abbas / Israeli Arabs / Zionist Organisations / Shin Bet / Haaretz
Posted in Palestine  
Related Articles
Netanyahu declines Obama's request to expand settlement freeze
Hamas: Resumption of settlement building exposes futility of negotiations
Netanyahu calls for resuming settlement activities quietly
12 Palestinians killed since the outset of direct peace talks
Voices for peace?
Palestinian man shot during peaceful anti-wall march south of Gaza
Empty Promises: Obama takes his Middle East peace plan to the UN
What if Peace Talks "Succeed?"
Obama speaks at the UN... Goodbye to peace
Jewish settlements can now be tracked on your iPhone
Settlers build near Palestinian villages on eve of peace talks
The Thin Green Line: It's Not Just the Settlements (or the Occupation), Stupid!
Prominent rabbi tells Erdogan: There can be no peace without Hamas
Coptic Solidarity calls on Mubarak to make peace in his country first
America's Faltering Search for Peace in the Middle East: Openings for Others? [Must read]
The parameters of peace
US Hamas policy blocks Middle East peace
George Mitchell hoping for a quick-fix fake peace?
U.S. gives Israel green light to build in 57 West Bank settlements
A Peace Plan Within Our Grasp
Mubarak hints succession by taking son to peace summit in Washington
Once again peace talks or no peace talks
Occupation plans to increase settlers in West Bank settlements
Palestinians protest against settlement and Judaization in Sheikh Jarrah area
Security forces barbarically invade houses of peaceful petitioners including MB leader
Kadima: Netanyahu not serious about peace talks with Fatah
Netanyahu refuses to extend settlement freeze
New bids to build hundreds of ‘settlement’ units in Jerusalem
MB chairman meets with Wafd Party leader, stress reform and peaceful change
Child, foreign activists hurt in IOF quelling of peaceful march
Time to crack down on settlement funding – by Yousef Munayyer
Study shows growing settlement activity and ethnic cleansing in Jerusalem
NYT: U.S. tax dollars used for settlement activity
New settlement project in disputed area of Jabal Mukaber in J'lem
Expert: Israel steals Gaza water to supply its settlements
Tahboub: The Palestinians inherited calamities from the logic of settlement
Default Positions: U.S. immigration & Israeli settlements
Lieberman: Settlement in Jerusalem will continue
Lieberman: No settlement freeze in Jerusalem
MP Adli: Egypt’s gas contributes to the building of Israeli settlements