Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Egypt’s 2010 Parliamentary Elections > Egypt’s 2010 Elections in the Western Media
Egypt Cracks Down as U.S. Stands By
Egypt Cracks Down as U.S. Stands By
In the face of police brutality, crackdowns on political parties and media, and a host of other violations ahead of Egypt's Nov. 28 parliamentary election, human rights advocates are calling on President Barack Obama to use U.S. leverage to persuade Egypt to reform its electoral process, allow international monitors to assess the election, and conduct transparent and accountable balloting.
Monday, November 8,2010 13:57
by William Fisher Ipsnews.net

 The Egyptian parliamentary election – and the presidential election to follow in September 2011 – is playing out against a background of years of police brutality and political corruption, buttressed by a so-called Emergency Law. That law, which has been in effect for three decades, gives police and security services sweeping powers to arrest and detain with little or no due process.

But administration critics say President Obama and his advisors have become too dependent on Egypt for its help to Israel regarding illegal smuggling from the Egyptian desert into Gaza, and helping maintain Arab neutrality vis a vis the Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.

While they acknowledge the value of this help, they contend that Egypt is acting in its own self-interest and would provide such help regardless of what the U.S. says about its electoral process.

One of the most vocal critics of President Hosni Mubarak's regime is Human Rights First, a New York City-based legal advocacy organisation. It is urging President Obama to publicly call on Egyptian authorities stop harassing ruling opposition party figures and open the parliamentary elections to international monitors.

Calls for a "Comprehensive Strategy"


Michele Dunne, senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and editor of the online journal, the Arab Reform Bulletin, told IPS, "I think that the United States should advocate democratisation and greater respect for human rights for Egyptians. This does not mean that the U.S. can make these things happen in Egypt, but we should be clear that we are in favor and willing to use the influence we have to promote them."

She added, "Public comments can make clear to Egyptian citizens where the United States stands on these issues - which has a value in and of itself - but clearly are not enough to have an effect on the calculations of the Egyptian government. That would require a more comprehensive strategy that considers public comment, private diplomacy, assistance programmes, and other forms of engagement with the Egyptian government and Egyptian citizens - which is exactly was has been missing from U.S. policy so far."

As to pro-democracy programmes, Dunne told IPS, these "are helpful partly for the resources they offer and even more so from the implied U.S. support for pro-democracy groups in Egypt. But they can only assist and support a pro-democracy movement from Egyptian society itself, not create one from outside."

"By the way," she said, "the obvious question is whether the United States can do this and still cooperate with the Egyptian government on the Arab- Israeli peace process and other issues. The track record suggests that the answer is yes. The Egyptian government takes its decisions on Israel and other regional issues for its own national security reasons, not to do a favour for the U.S."

"The Egyptian government is using a 30-year state of emergency to make arbitrary arrests and violently repress political activists," said Neil Hicks, HRF's international policy advisor. "In preparation for upcoming elections this November, the government has silenced independent journalists, cracked down on activists and opposition candidates, and refused international election monitors."

"You need a license in Egypt to send a political text message," he added.

"The last round of elections in Egypt found policemen beating voters and officials grabbing ballot boxes," Hicks told IPS. "We cannot let that happen again."

The Egyptian government appears to be doing what it can to disrupt opposition plans to contest the Parliamentary election.

For example, the Associated Press reports that Egyptian security detained 65 members of the opposition Muslim Brotherhood while they were hanging election posters. Authorities said the posters violated a new ban on religious expressions. The government has arrested some 250 members of the Brotherhood and 30 remain in jails.

Media suppression has also been ratcheted up in the pre- election period.

For example, Egypt's National Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (NTRA), imposed new restrictions on text-message news services and mobile phone companies, in an apparent attempt to preempt possible anti-government activism during the polls.

And the Egyptian Ministry of Information now compels satellite channels to obtain licenses before broadcasting an event live or distributing news reports to other television channels.

The anti-media campaign has also included the firing of one of the country's better-known veteran journalists, who was editor of the main opposition newspaper. He had recently also been fired from his television talk show.

In another media move, authorities closed the religious conservative satellite television network, Al-Badr, for inciting sectarian hatred, and shut down the studios that produced the political talk show "Al-Qahira il-Youm" ("Cairo Today").

These actions have triggered calls from some for international monitors to supervise the election, and from others for a campaign to boycott the balloting altogether.

Washington has had little to say of current developments. Obama's predecessor, George W. Bush, had taken an increasing interest in the need for political reform and human rights improvements inside Egypt, a position associated with his neoconservative vision of Washington spreading democracy around the world.

But the Bush position caused considerable friction between the two governments, and Obama returned to seeing Egypt as a peace process partner.

The Mubarak regime, however, has made the U.S. position difficult to maintain. For example, President Mubarak had promised to lift the state of emergency, which has been in effect since 1981 and significantly curbs civil liberties inside Egypt. But it chose to renew it instead. That drew a stiff protest from the Obama administration.

President Obama has also dramatically cut funds to promote democracy in Egypt. The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reports that these cuts over the past year - amounting to around 50 percent - have drawn accusations that the Obama administration is easing off reform pressure to ensure Egypt's support on Mideast policy, including the peace process with Israel.

Egypt has been one of the top recipients of U.S. foreign aid ever since it became the first Arab country to sign a peace accord with Israel, in 1979.

Since the Bush administration, Washington has been reducing the nonmilitary part of the package. This year's aid is $1.55 billion, including $250 million in nonmilitary aid. In 2008, the Bush administration dedicated around $45 million of that to programmes for "governing justly and democratically".

The Obama administration's slash in these pro-democracy programmes has drawn a mixed response. Some contend they are ineffective and merely plant seeds of discord between the U.S. and Cairo. Others think they have a place.

Samer Shehata, a professor of Arab politics at Georgetown University, minimises the importance of the U.S. pro- democracy programmes.

"The real issue is what - or what not - the White House and State Department are saying publicly, and privately to the Egyptian government, about the upcoming elections," he told IPS.

"The Obama administration is unfortunately not interested in pushing the sclerotic Mubarak regime (Mubarak is 82, in declining health and without a vice president) to display even mild respect for political freedoms, including free and fair elections," he said.


tags: Egyptian Election / Egyptian Parliament / Obama / Political Reform / Emergency Law / Mubarak / Mubarak Regime / Egyptian Authorities / Egyptian Government / Political Detainees / Political Activists / MB Candidate / MB Arrests / NGOs / Democracy in Egypt / Peace Talk / / Obama Administration / Israeli-Palestinian Peace / Opposition Candidates / Moderate Muslim Brotherhood / Moderate MB / Egyptian Citizens / Egyptian Media /
Posted in Egypt’s 2010 Elections in the Western Media  
Related Articles
Breaking news: All MB candidates in Alexandria vying for parliamentary seats in the workers sector have been written off the candidates list.
Obama NSC meets with Egypt democracy advocates
57 MB candidates barred from registering in elections
Evidence of U.S. backtracking on supporting democracy in Egypt
Breaking news: 75 MB candidates submitted applications despite escalating aggression
Egypt elections: Hosni Mubarak awaits his managed landslide
Obama's half-hearted efforts for Egyptian democracy
Obama's task on Egyptian democracy
Amnesty Calls on Egyptian Authorities to Release Political Detainees
President Obama puts political expediency ahead of US Constitution and civil liberties
The Legacy of Mubarak
US scholar calls on Mubarak to end unjustified attacks on students
50 MB arrested in 7 governorates following the MB announcement of its participation in elections
MB political detainees levelled with fabricated accusations
Finding Meaning in the Egyptian Elections
Gaza-bound convoy hopes Egypt will allow its passage to Gaza
12 Palestinians killed since the outset of direct peace talks
What if Peace Talks "Succeed?"
Analysts describe MB as driving force behind ElBaradei's online bid for political reform
On whose behalf is Egypt savaging the people of Gaza ?
Student from Gaza tells story of his torture by Egyptian officers
Egyptians unite in silent protest against police brutality and emergency law
Alexandria: MB, ElBaradei and political activists protest against police brutality
MB and NAC cooperate for political reform
Towards the Release of Detainees under the Emergency Law … Egypt without the Emergency Law
Egypt: Activists demand release of political detainees
Egyptian government fails to fulfill promises to protect human rights
Egyptian authorities refuse entry of construction material via Rafah terminal
Tensions rise as Shura's opposition candidates face difficulties
Egyptian citizens in the US demand right to vote in Egyptian elections
Egyptian authorities to demolish houses to complete building the steel wall
Parliamentary criticism of attacking Political Activists
MB chairman: MB support Dr.Baradei's call for Political Reform
In Egypt, the Twilight of the Mubarak Regime
US Dances Around Stance on Democracy in Egypt
Analysts call on Washington to pressure Egypt for political reform
Egyptian government is questioned on the disappearance of LE 1272 billion
UPR: Egyptian government Vs NGOs
MB MPs excellent performance in the Egyptian Parliament
Egypt-Algeria World Cup violence used to rally support for Mubarak regime
Failed Israeli-Palestinian Peace Talks May Sink Obama's Middle East Strategy
6 MB arrested in Monofeya raid
12 MB arrested in Alexandria raid
How to Achieve Israeli-Palestinian Peace
Widespread anger in Egypt at Mubarak regime
Egypt: regime targets activists, NGOs
US expresses concerns over Egyptian elections
Egyptian elections: Brotherhood says it’s ready
700 potential opposition candidates arrested ahead of Egypt’s elections: Islamist lawmaker
Dunne: ‘Very Dramatic’ Achievement for Muslim Brotherhood in Egyptian Parliamentary Elections
Female Islamist eyes Egyptian parliament seat
The Moderate Muslim Brotherhood