Ikhwanweb :: The Muslim Brotherhood Official English Website

Thu93 2020

Last update18:06 PM GMT

Back to Homepage
Font Size : 12 point 14 point 16 point 18 point
:: Egypt’s 2010 Parliamentary Elections > 2010 election update
Opaque and Messy Elections
Opaque and Messy Elections
As results come in for Egypt’s People’s Assembly elections—surprise, a victory for the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP)—they are likely to enjoy little credibility either inside or outside the country due to the total lack of transparency and the widespread irregularities and violence that characterized the voting and counting processes.
Wednesday, December 1,2010 02:15
by Michele Dunne Carnegie Endowment

 As results come in for Egypt’s People’s Assembly elections—surprise, a victory for the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP)—they are likely to enjoy little credibility either inside or outside the country due to the total lack of transparency and the widespread irregularities and violence that characterized the voting and counting processes. 

Extensive restrictions on media coverage and civil society monitoring ensured that there would be little transparency on election day. Egyptian authorities prevented live satellite broadcasts from the country and cancelled planned television programs by major media outlets, including the BBC.

After rebuffing the requests of international organizations to observe the elections on the excuse that there would be an extensive domestic monitoring effort, Egyptian authorities impeded the work of local civil society monitors. Only a small percentage were granted official credentials, and then most of those credentialed were either denied entry to polling and counting stations or evicted after they entered. (Similarly, representatives of opposition candidates were excluded from polling stations in many locations even if they had official credentials, while representatives of ruling party candidates were admitted.)

While the Higher Electoral Commission, which was charged with supervising the parliamentary elections, responded to early complaints about monitor exclusion by saying it would look into the problem, the commission itself created the problem by issuing overly restrictive regulations for monitoring—stipulating, for example, that credentialed monitors could enter polling stations only with the permission of the polling station chair, as if the credentials did not in themselves constitute permission.

Although monitors mostly watched the elections from outside polling places, they observed signs of widespread electoral fraud, in particular ballot box stuffing. Monitors witnessed or received eyewitness accounts (as well as video evidence) of voting stations being closed for hours while poll workers wrote out ballot after ballot, and of supporters of ruling party candidates arriving at voting stations bearing large plastic bags full of voter cards or completed ballots. Outside the polling places, vote buying proceeded as usual, with the price for a vote varying according to the location and the time of day.

Coercion and intimidation also featured in the Egyptian elections, primarily perpetrated by “baltagiyya,” thugs hired either by the security services or by individual candidates. Thugs kept voters out of certain polling stations for hours at a time, expelled civil society monitors and journalists by force, and intimidated or beat up campaign workers or thugs working for other candidates. A few of the thugs reportedly worked for Muslim Brotherhood candidates, but the vast majority appeared to be affiliated with the regime or the National Democratic Party and were tolerated by uniformed security.

With the baltagiyya on hand to do the dirty work, uniformed security officers appeared to be better behaved than in previous elections and there were fewer reports of security cordons around polling places in order to exclude or intimidate voters.

Among the little-noticed surprises of the elections was an announcement that Coptic Pope Shenouda had voted for an opposition candidate, Rami Lakah (a Copt) of the Wafd Party. This was in stark contrast to the Pope’s stance during the 2005 elections, when he instructed Copts that it was their duty to vote for the ruling National Democratic Party and went so far as to excommunicate several Copts who chose to run as opposition candidates. While Shenouda’s change of heart will not affect the election results, it is a strong sign of his displeasure with the regime’s handling of simmering sectarian tensions, including an incident the week before elections in which security services provoked unrest by disrupting the construction of a church, resulting in the killing of one young Coptic man.

Sectarian conflicts are among several other issues—economic dissatisfaction, police brutality and torture, and public safety problems—souring the attitude of Egyptians toward the government and keeping the internal situation at a simmer, if not a boil. A parliamentary election seen by Egyptians as having been stolen will turn the temperature up another notch.



tags: NDP / Elections / Egyptian Authorities / International Organizations / Opposition Candidates / Ruling Party Candidates
Posted in 2010 election update  
Related Articles
Egypt: Elections Marred as Opposition Barred from Polls
Voting Ends in Bloody Parliamentary Elections in Egypt
Egypt Is Holding Elections: Will They Matter?
Elections Update:Egypt goes to poll with no sign of democracy
Forging, Arrests and Beatings on the First Day of Elections
Independent Coalition: Government Has Started Rigging Elections and HEC Speaks on Behalf of the Interior Ministry
The Supreme Administrative Court issues a verdict obliging the Supreme Committee for Elections to implement the State Council's rulings
Elections eve and heightened hostilities against MB opposition
Egypt: Authorities urged to safeguard rights during elections
Egyptian regime clampsdown on critics in the lead up to elections
2010 Egyptian Elections – A Farce of Dragon Proportions
Dr Morsy to al-Arabiya: Supervision Is the Most Effective Means to Combat Rigging of the Elections
MB Chairman Demands International Supervision of Elections
Egyptian Court Refuses Nomination of Senior Government Official for the Upcoming Parliamentary Elections
Journalists and Media Workers: No Hope for Neutral Media Coverage for the Upcoming Elections
Egypt’s Unobserved Elections
Kefaya Organizing a Demonstration on December 12 Calling for Re-Elections
Liberties Committee of the Egyptian Lawyers' Syndicate Calls for an End to Parliamentary Elections
Egyptian Government Dismisses US Concerns on Elections and Opposes Report on Religious Freedom
Abu El-Fotouh: Egypt's NDP to Run Elections with Guerrilla Thinking